Hey guys! Are you a fan of the hilarious and heartwarming police sitcom Brooklyn Nine-Nine? Of course, you are! Who isn't? This show has given us some truly unforgettable moments, lovable characters, and gut-busting humor. But with so many episodes, it's natural to wonder which ones really stand out. So, let's dive into the best Brooklyn 99 episodes, ranked according to their IMDb ratings. Get ready to revisit some of the Nine-Nine's finest work!

Why IMDb Ratings Matter

Before we jump into the list, let's briefly talk about why IMDb ratings are a useful metric. IMDb (Internet Movie Database) is a widely used platform where users can rate movies and TV shows on a scale of 1 to 10. These ratings reflect the collective opinion of a large audience, giving you a general idea of how well-received an episode is. While taste is subjective, high IMDb ratings often indicate strong writing, compelling storylines, outstanding performances, and overall quality.

It’s worth noting that IMDb ratings aren’t the only way to judge an episode. Personal preferences play a huge role. What one person finds hilarious, another might find just okay. However, these ratings provide a solid starting point for discovering or re-watching some of the series' most acclaimed episodes. Moreover, a higher rating indicates that the episode resonated with a broader audience, suggesting that it successfully executed its comedic or emotional goals.

IMDb ratings also help in recognizing trends. Episodes that consistently receive high scores often feature significant character development, pivotal plot points, or exceptional guest appearances. They can also highlight the moments where the show's writers and actors were firing on all cylinders, creating comedic gold that stands the test of time. So, when you're looking for a guaranteed laugh or a heartwarming moment, checking the IMDb ratings can point you in the right direction. Plus, it's always fun to see if your personal favorites align with the general consensus!

Top Brooklyn 99 Episodes According to IMDb

Alright, let's get to the good stuff! Here's a rundown of some of the highest-rated Brooklyn 99 episodes on IMDb, which showcase the show's brilliance. Keep in mind that ratings can fluctuate, but these episodes are consistently ranked among the best.

"The Box" (Season 5, Episode 14) - Rating: 9.7

Often considered one of the best Brooklyn 99 episodes ever made, "The Box" is a masterclass in tension and acting. In this episode, Jake Peralta (Andy Samberg) and Captain Holt (Andre Braugher) engage in an intense overnight interrogation with a suspect (Sterling K. Brown) accused of murder. The entire episode takes place in a single room, relying solely on dialogue and the incredible performances of the three actors.

What makes "The Box" so compelling is the psychological battle of wits between Jake and the suspect. Jake, known for his immature and impulsive behavior, must maintain his focus and use his detective skills to crack the case. Holt, with his stoic demeanor, provides a fascinating contrast and adds layers of complexity to the interrogation. The episode is filled with clever twists and turns, keeping you on the edge of your seat until the very end. It demonstrates the show’s ability to transcend its comedic roots and deliver a genuinely gripping and dramatic narrative.

Sterling K. Brown's guest appearance is a significant factor in the episode's success. He delivers a nuanced and captivating performance, matching wits with Samberg and Braugher and creating a palpable sense of tension. The episode also explores the dynamic between Jake and Holt, highlighting their mutual respect and the unique bond they share. It's a standout episode that showcases the show's versatility and its ability to surprise and delight its audience. With its exceptional writing, acting, and direction, “The Box” easily earns its place as one of the highest-rated episodes of Brooklyn Nine-Nine.

"O Captain! My Captain!" (Season 8, Episode 10) - Rating: 9.7

The series finale, "O Captain! My Captain!" is a fitting and emotional farewell to the Brooklyn Nine-Nine team. In this episode, Captain Holt is leaving the Nine-Nine to take a position as Deputy Commissioner, and the squad comes together to plan one last heist to honor him. The episode is packed with callbacks to previous seasons, heartwarming moments, and plenty of laughs.

What makes this finale so special is its ability to balance humor and sentimentality. It acknowledges the changes happening in the characters' lives while celebrating the bonds they've formed over the years. The heist itself is cleverly designed, incorporating elements from past heists and giving each character a chance to shine. It's a love letter to the fans, filled with Easter eggs and references that will bring a smile to any longtime viewer's face.

The episode also addresses the themes of change and growth, as each character reflects on their journey throughout the series. Jake, in particular, grapples with the idea of Holt leaving and what it means for their relationship. The finale provides closure for the characters while leaving the door open for their future adventures. With its perfect blend of comedy, emotion, and nostalgia, "O Captain! My Captain!" is a satisfying conclusion to a beloved series and a worthy addition to the list of best Brooklyn 99 episodes.

"Halloween IV" (Season 4, Episode 5) - Rating: 9.5

The Halloween heists are a Brooklyn 99 tradition, and "Halloween IV" is one of the best. In this episode, the squad competes to steal a plaque and be crowned the ultimate human/genius. The twists and turns are endless, and the episode is full of surprises.

What makes the Halloween heists so entertaining is the elaborate planning and scheming that goes into each competition. The characters are constantly trying to outsmart each other, leading to hilarious betrayals and unexpected alliances. "Halloween IV" is particularly memorable because it introduces new elements to the heist, such as the use of costumes and disguises. The episode also showcases the characters' competitive spirit and their willingness to go to extreme lengths to win.

The dynamic between Jake and Amy (Melissa Fumero) is a highlight of this episode, as their relationship is put to the test during the heist. The episode also features memorable moments from other characters, such as Boyle's (Joe Lo Truglio) unwavering loyalty to Jake and Rosa's (Stephanie Beatriz) deadpan humor. With its clever writing, fast-paced action, and plenty of laughs, "Halloween IV" is a must-watch episode and a testament to the show's comedic genius. It exemplifies why the Halloween heists are such a beloved part of Brooklyn Nine-Nine.

"HalloVeen" (Season 5, Episode 4) - Rating: 9.4

Another Halloween heist episode, "HalloVeen," takes things to a whole new level. In this episode, Jake proposes to Amy during the heist, making it a truly unforgettable moment. The episode is full of the usual heist shenanigans, but the emotional stakes are higher than ever.

What sets "HalloVeen" apart is its perfect blend of comedy and romance. The heist itself is cleverly designed, with each character playing a crucial role in Jake's proposal. The episode is filled with surprises and unexpected twists, keeping the audience guessing until the very end. The proposal scene is heartwarming and genuine, capturing the essence of Jake and Amy's relationship.

The episode also features memorable moments from other characters, such as Holt's reaction to the proposal and Boyle's over-the-top enthusiasm. The dynamic between Jake and Amy is the heart of this episode, and their chemistry is undeniable. With its perfect balance of humor, romance, and suspense, "HalloVeen" is a standout episode and a testament to the show's ability to tug at our heartstrings while making us laugh out loud. It’s a memorable entry to the best Brooklyn 99 episodes.

"The Night Shift" (Season 3, Episode 16) - Rating: 9.3

"The Night Shift" offers a glimpse into the challenges and camaraderie of working the night shift at the Nine-Nine. In this episode, Jake and Amy work together on a case, while Holt and Rosa deal with a quirky complaint. The episode is a great example of the show's ensemble cast and its ability to balance multiple storylines.

What makes "The Night Shift" so enjoyable is its focus on character interactions and relationships. Jake and Amy's partnership is put to the test as they navigate the challenges of working together on a case. Holt and Rosa's storyline provides plenty of comedic relief, as they deal with a series of bizarre complaints. The episode also highlights the importance of teamwork and the bonds that form between colleagues.

The episode features memorable moments from each character, showcasing their unique personalities and quirks. The dynamic between Jake and Amy is particularly strong in this episode, as they work together to solve a case and support each other through the challenges of the night shift. With its balanced storylines, strong character interactions, and plenty of laughs, "The Night Shift" is a solid episode that showcases the show's strengths. It’s an excellent example of why Brooklyn Nine-Nine resonates with so many viewers.

Other Highly-Rated Episodes

While the above episodes are consistently ranked among the highest, there are plenty of other Brooklyn 99 episodes that deserve recognition. Here are a few more favorites:

• "Johnny and Dora" (Season 3, Episode 12): Jake and Amy go undercover as a couple. Rating: 9.2
• "The Wednesday Incident" (Season 5, Episode 22): A case forces Jake and Amy to work separately. Rating: 9.1
• "9 Days" (Season 6, Episode 18): Jake and Holt are quarantined together with the mumps. Rating: 9.0

Conclusion

So there you have it, folks! A look at some of the best Brooklyn Nine-Nine episodes, according to IMDb ratings. Whether you're a longtime fan or a newcomer to the series, these episodes are sure to provide plenty of laughs, heartwarming moments, and unforgettable memories. Now go forth and binge-watch responsibly! And remember, Nine-Nine!