Hey cycling enthusiasts! Today, we're diving deep into the world of classic bike saddles with a Brooks B17 Carved saddle review. If you're on the hunt for a saddle that blends timeless design with comfort for those long rides, you've probably heard about the Brooks B17. It's an iconic piece of cycling gear, but is it right for you? Let's break it down.

What is Brooks B17 Carved Saddle?

The Brooks B17 Carved saddle is a variation of the classic B17 model, featuring a cutout designed to relieve pressure in the perineal area. The Brooks B17 itself has been a staple in the cycling world for over a century, known for its durability, quality, and the way it molds to the rider's body over time. The 'Carved' version aims to address a common concern among cyclists: pressure and discomfort during extended rides. This saddle, like its predecessor, is made from high-quality vegetable-tanned leather, ensuring both longevity and a unique aesthetic that ages beautifully. Brooks England has a long-standing reputation for crafting saddles that are not just functional but also pieces of art. The B17 Carved is no exception, with its hand-hammered rivets and classic design adding a touch of elegance to any bicycle. It's a saddle that tells a story, one of tradition, craftsmanship, and a commitment to rider comfort. Whether you're a seasoned cyclist or new to the world of biking, the Brooks B17 Carved offers a blend of heritage and modern ergonomics that's hard to ignore. The saddle's ability to adapt to the rider's anatomy over time makes it a worthwhile investment for those seeking a personalized and comfortable cycling experience. With proper care, a Brooks B17 Carved saddle can last for decades, becoming a trusted companion on countless adventures. This saddle isn't just about getting from point A to point B; it's about enjoying the journey with a saddle that feels like it was made just for you. For cyclists who value both style and substance, the Brooks B17 Carved represents a perfect harmony of form and function. It's a saddle that not only performs well but also adds a touch of class to any bike, making it a standout choice for discerning riders.

First Impressions: Unboxing and Installation

Alright, let's talk first impressions. When you get your hands on a Brooks B17 Carved saddle, the first thing you'll notice is the quality. This isn't some mass-produced, plastic-y thing. It's a real leather saddle, and it feels like it. The smell of the leather is a dead giveaway! The packaging is simple but elegant, reflecting the brand's commitment to quality. Unboxing the saddle feels like unwrapping a piece of cycling history. The rich, natural leather and the meticulously crafted details speak volumes about the care and attention that goes into each Brooks saddle. Holding it in your hands, you can feel the weight of tradition and the promise of countless comfortable rides to come. The installation process is straightforward, especially if you're familiar with standard saddle setups. The B17 Carved fits easily onto most seatposts, and adjusting the position is a breeze. However, it's essential to take your time and ensure the saddle is properly aligned for optimal comfort and performance. A quick tip: use a level to make sure the saddle is perfectly horizontal. This will help prevent any unnecessary strain or discomfort during your rides. During installation, pay attention to the tensioning bolt at the nose of the saddle. This bolt allows you to adjust the leather's tension, which is crucial for achieving the perfect level of support and comfort. Start with the bolt slightly loose and gradually tighten it as the leather begins to stretch and conform to your body. Remember, patience is key. It takes time for the leather to break in and mold to your unique shape. But once it does, you'll have a saddle that feels like it was custom-made just for you. Overall, the initial impression of the Brooks B17 Carved is one of quality, craftsmanship, and timeless design. It's a saddle that exudes class and promises a comfortable and enjoyable cycling experience. From the moment you unbox it to the first time you install it on your bike, you'll appreciate the attention to detail and the commitment to excellence that Brooks puts into every saddle they make.

Comfort and Performance: Riding the B17 Carved

Now for the important part: How does the Brooks B17 Carved saddle actually feel when you're riding? The B17 Carved is designed for long-distance comfort. The leather provides a degree of natural suspension, and the cutout helps to alleviate pressure. However, it's important to note that there's a break-in period. When you first start riding on the B17 Carved, it might feel a bit firm. Don't let that discourage you! Over time, the leather will mold to your unique anatomy, creating a customized fit that's incredibly comfortable. During the break-in period, it's a good idea to apply some Brooks Proofide leather dressing to help soften the leather and speed up the molding process. Regular application of Proofide will also help to protect the leather from the elements and keep it in top condition. As the saddle breaks in, you'll notice that it starts to conform to your sit bones, providing excellent support and reducing pressure points. The cutout in the Carved version is particularly effective at relieving pressure in the perineal area, which can help to prevent numbness and discomfort during long rides. One of the key benefits of the Brooks B17 Carved is its ability to adapt to different riding styles. Whether you're commuting to work, touring the countryside, or tackling challenging trails, this saddle provides consistent comfort and support. The wide platform of the B17 Carved also accommodates a variety of riding positions, allowing you to shift your weight and maintain a comfortable posture throughout your ride. The Brooks B17 Carved is a saddle that rewards patience. It takes time and effort to break it in properly, but once it's molded to your body, you'll have a saddle that provides unparalleled comfort and performance. It's an investment in your cycling enjoyment that will pay off for years to come. The B17 Carved isn't just a saddle; it's a companion that will accompany you on countless adventures, providing the support and comfort you need to explore the world on two wheels. For cyclists who value both comfort and durability, the Brooks B17 Carved is a clear winner. It's a saddle that's built to last, providing years of reliable performance and a level of comfort that few other saddles can match. So, if you're looking for a saddle that will transform your cycling experience, look no further than the Brooks B17 Carved.

Pros and Cons: Weighing the Options

Like any product, the Brooks B17 Carved saddle has its pros and cons. Let's lay them out:

Pros:

• Unmatched Comfort (Once Broken In): Seriously, once it molds to you, it's like a custom seat.
• Durability: These saddles are known to last for decades with proper care.
• Timeless Style: It looks fantastic on classic and modern bikes alike.
• Pressure Relief: The cutout does a great job of reducing pressure.

Cons:

• Break-In Period: It can take some time and effort to get it just right.
• Price: Brooks saddles are an investment.
• Weight: It's heavier than many modern saddles.
• Requires Maintenance: You'll need to apply Proofide regularly.

The Brooks B17 Carved saddle is a product that demands patience but rewards its user with unparalleled comfort and durability. The initial investment may seem steep, but the saddle's longevity and the comfort it provides make it a worthwhile purchase for serious cyclists. The break-in period, while a potential drawback, is also part of the saddle's charm. It's a process of personalization, where the saddle gradually adapts to your unique anatomy, becoming a perfect fit over time. The maintenance required, although a con for some, is also an opportunity to bond with your saddle. Applying Proofide is a simple task that can be done while reflecting on past rides and planning future adventures. It's a ritual that connects you to the saddle and ensures its long-term health and performance. The weight of the saddle, while heavier than modern alternatives, is a testament to its robust construction and the quality of materials used. It's a trade-off for the durability and longevity that Brooks saddles are known for. Despite the cons, the pros of the Brooks B17 Carved far outweigh the drawbacks for many cyclists. The comfort, durability, and timeless style of the saddle make it a classic choice for those who value quality and craftsmanship. It's a saddle that will last for years, providing a comfortable and enjoyable cycling experience. For those who are willing to invest the time and effort required to break it in and maintain it, the Brooks B17 Carved is a saddle that will transform your cycling experience.

Alternatives to the Brooks B17 Carved

If you're not entirely sold on the Brooks B17 Carved saddle, here are a few alternatives to consider:

• Brooks B17 Standard: The classic version without the cutout. If you don't need the pressure relief, this is a great option.
• Selle Anatomica X Series: Known for their immediate comfort and flexibility.
• Specialized Power Saddle: A modern, performance-oriented saddle with a focus on pressure relief.
• ISM Adamo Saddles: Designed to eliminate pressure on the perineum, popular among triathletes.

When considering alternatives to the Brooks B17 Carved, it's essential to evaluate your specific needs and preferences. The Brooks B17 Standard, for example, offers the same classic design and quality craftsmanship as the Carved version but without the cutout. This can be a good option for riders who don't experience pressure issues or prefer a more traditional feel. Selle Anatomica saddles are known for their immediate comfort and flexibility, making them a popular choice for riders who want a saddle that feels good right out of the box. These saddles feature a unique design that allows the leather to flex and conform to your body, providing excellent support and reducing pressure points. Specialized Power saddles are a modern alternative that focuses on performance and pressure relief. These saddles are designed with a wide, flat profile and a cutout to minimize pressure on soft tissues, making them a good choice for riders who prioritize speed and efficiency. ISM Adamo saddles are specifically designed to eliminate pressure on the perineum, making them a popular choice among triathletes and cyclists who experience numbness or discomfort in that area. These saddles feature a unique split-nose design that allows the rider to sit on their sit bones, reducing pressure on sensitive areas. Ultimately, the best alternative to the Brooks B17 Carved will depend on your individual needs and preferences. It's essential to try out different saddles and find one that fits your body and riding style. Consider factors such as the shape, width, padding, and materials of the saddle, and don't be afraid to experiment until you find the perfect fit.

Final Verdict: Is the Brooks B17 Carved Worth It?

So, is the Brooks B17 Carved saddle worth it? For many cyclists, the answer is a resounding yes. If you value comfort, durability, and timeless style, and you're willing to put in the time and effort to break it in and maintain it, the B17 Carved is an excellent choice. However, if you're on a tight budget, prefer a maintenance-free saddle, or prioritize lightweight performance above all else, there may be better options out there. Ultimately, the decision comes down to your individual needs and priorities. The Brooks B17 Carved is a saddle that embodies a rich tradition of craftsmanship and quality. It's a saddle that's built to last, providing years of comfortable and reliable performance. It's an investment in your cycling enjoyment that will pay off for years to come. For cyclists who value both style and substance, the Brooks B17 Carved represents a perfect harmony of form and function. It's a saddle that not only performs well but also adds a touch of class to any bike, making it a standout choice for discerning riders. If you're considering purchasing a Brooks B17 Carved, take the time to do your research and read reviews from other cyclists. Consider your riding style, the types of rides you typically do, and your individual comfort preferences. If possible, try out the saddle before you buy it to ensure that it's a good fit for your body. Remember, the break-in period is a crucial part of the process. Don't be discouraged if the saddle feels uncomfortable at first. With patience and persistence, it will gradually mold to your body and become one of the most comfortable saddles you've ever ridden. The Brooks B17 Carved is more than just a saddle; it's a statement of quality, craftsmanship, and a commitment to cycling enjoyment. It's a saddle that will accompany you on countless adventures, providing the support and comfort you need to explore the world on two wheels. If you're looking for a saddle that will last a lifetime and provide unparalleled comfort, the Brooks B17 Carved is an investment that's well worth considering.